WB JEE
General Organic Chemistry PYQWB JEE 2020
MCQ+1 / -0.252020
For the following carbocations, the correct order of stability is
I.
II.
III.
I.
II.
III.
Solution
Correct option: D
Correct option: D. The stability order is I < III < II.
Step 1
Carbocations become more stable with electron donation such as +R, +I or hyperconjugation, and less stable with electron withdrawal such as -R or -I effects.
Step 2
In I, the adjacent carbonyl group has an electron-withdrawing effect, so it destabilises the carbocation: is the least stable.
Step 3
In III, the methyl group can stabilise the carbocation by hyperconjugation, so is more stable than I.
Step 4
In II, the methoxy group donates electron density by the +R effect, giving the strongest stabilisation to .
Step 5
Thus, the correct increasing order of stability is . Hence, the correct option is D.
