NEET
Thermodynamics PYQAIPMT 2001
MCQ+4 / -12001
PbO2 PbO; G298 < 0
SnO2 SnO; G298 > 0
Most probable oxidation state of Pb and Sn will be
SnO2
Most probable oxidation state of Pb and Sn will be
Solution
Correct option: D
Pb2+, Sn4+
Check lead conversion
In PbO2, Pb is in the oxidation state, while in PbO, Pb is in the oxidation state.
Use Gibbs energy for Pb
For PbO2 PbO, , so the conversion is spontaneous. Thus Pb4+ changes to Pb2+ readily.
Infer stable Pb state
Since Pb2+ is formed spontaneously, the most probable oxidation state of Pb is .
Check tin conversion
In SnO2, Sn is , and in SnO, Sn is . But for SnO2 SnO, , so this change is not spontaneous.
Infer stable Sn state
Since Sn4+ does not spontaneously convert to Sn2+, the most probable oxidation state of Sn is . Hence, option D is correct.
