JEE Advanced
Motion PYQIIT-JEE 2008 Paper 2 Offline
opposite direction to the train, while the distant objects appear to be stationary.
STATEMENT-2: If the observer and the object are moving at velocities
and
respectively with reference to a laboratory frame, the
velocity of the object with respect to the observer is
Solution
Correct option: B
Answer: B. Both statements are true, but Statement-2 does not correctly explain Statement-1.
Check Statement-1
For a passenger in a fast-moving train, nearby objects seem to move backward quickly, while very far objects appear almost fixed.
Use Angular Motion Idea
This apparent effect depends on angular speed. A nearby object subtends a larger changing angle, so its angular speed relative to the observer is large.
Compare With Distant Objects
For distant objects, the angular change is very small, so their apparent motion is negligible. Hence Statement-1 is true.
Check Statement-2
The relative velocity formula is correct:
Conclusion
Statement-2 states the general relative velocity relation, but Statement-1 is explained by angular speed. Therefore, Statement-2 is not the correct explanation of Statement-1.
