JEE Advanced
Some Basic Concepts Of Chemistry PYQIIT-JEE 1991
STATEMENT (S): In the titration of Na2CO3 with HCl using methyl orange indicator, the volume required at the equivalence point is twice that of the acid required using phenolphthalein indicator.
EXPLANATION (E): Two moles of HCl are required for the complete neutralization of one mole of Na2CO3
Solution
Correct option: B
Check the first endpoint
With phenolphthalein, sodium carbonate is neutralized only up to bicarbonate:
This consumes one equivalent of HCl.
Check the methyl orange endpoint
With methyl orange, bicarbonate is further neutralized:
Compare acid volumes
The methyl orange endpoint includes both stages, so it needs two equivalents of HCl. The phenolphthalein endpoint needs only one equivalent.
Hence, the HCl volume at the methyl orange endpoint is twice that at the phenolphthalein endpoint.
Judge S and E
The statement is true. The explanation is also true because complete neutralization of
However, E does not explain the volume comparison in terms of the different indicator endpoints.
